KM Research Hub
← 返回论文库
已完成 入排:符合 图源:可得 入排置信度 0.98

Proton versus photon radiotherapy for patients with oropharyngeal cancer in the USA: a multicentre, randomised, open-label, non-inferiority phase 3 trial.

Steven J Frank, Paul M Busse, J Jack Lee, David I Rosenthal, Mike Hernandez, David M Swanson, Adam S Garden, G Brandon Gunn, Samir H Patel, James W Snider, Daniel J Ma, Jason K Molitoris, Nancy Y Lee, Upendra Parvathaneni, Mark W McDonald, Noah S Kalman, Alexander Lin, Nasiruddin Mohammed, Christina Henson, Christian Hyde, Gopal K Bajaj, Sanford R Katz, Roi Dagan, William H Morrison, Jay P Reddy, C David Fuller, Shalin J Shah, Jack Phan, Gregory M Chronowski, Lauren Mayo, Erich M Sturgis, Renata Ferrarotto, Xiaorong R Zhu, Xiaodong Zhang, Li Wang, Katherine A Hutcheson, Adel K El-Naggar, Amy C Moreno, Anna Lee, Michael T Spiotto, Neil D Gross, Stephen Y Lai, Jay J Liao, Jonathan Paly, Zhongxing Liao, Robert L Foote, University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center Clinical Trial Consortium

Lancet 407(10524) 174-184

PMID41391462
PMCIDPMC12812248
DOI10.1016/S0140-6736(25)01962-2
发表日期2025-12-14
入排依据:原始人体肿瘤 Phase III 随机药物试验,并报告 time-to-event 疗效结局。
图像/No. at risk 复核:KM 曲线已提取;No. at risk 信息待人工复核,不影响当前曲线图像显示。
摘要

摘要

BACKGROUND: Radiotherapy is an integral component of treatment for oropharyngeal cancer. Toxicity from the current state-of-the-art photon radiotherapy, intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT), has prompted the search for alternative, less toxic therapies. One such alternative that might de-intensify treatment is proton therapy. In this trial, we aimed to directly compare IMRT with intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT), both concurrent with systemic therapy, hypothesising comparable disease control and survival and lower toxicity. METHODS: This randomised, multicentre, open-label, non-inferiority, phase 3 trial was conducted in 21 sites (cancer centres or universities) in the USA. Patients (aged ≥18 years) with stage III or stage IV oropharyngeal cancer and an Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group performance status of 0-2 were recruited and randomly assigned 1:1 to receive IMPT or IMRT. All patients were treated with radiotherapy to 70 Gy in 33 fractions to the primary tumour site and cervical lymphadenopathy. The type, schedule, and dose of induction or concurrent systemic therapy were chosen locally by each institution's multidisciplinary tumour board and were consistent with international guidelines. The primary endpoint was progression-free survival and was assessed in the intention-to-treat population; safety outcomes were assessed in the per-protocol population (ie, patients who received the assigned therapy). A non-inferiority margin of 9 percentage points for progression-free survival at 3 years was used. This trial is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT01893307) and is closed to further accrual after prespecified interim analysis. FINDINGS: From Oct 10, 2013, to May 1, 2022, 440 patients consented (median age 61 years [IQR 55-68], 399 [91%] male, 409 [93%] White); 221 were allocated to the IMPT group (with 160 [72%] receiving IMPT) and 219 to the IMRT group (136 [62%] receiving IMRT). At a median follow-up time of 3·2 years, progression-free survival rates for the IMPT group were 82·5% (95% CI 76·1-87·3) at 3 years and 81·3% (74·5-86·5) at 5 years; corresponding rates for the IMRT group were 83·0% (76·7-87·7) and 76·2% (68·0-82·6; hazard ratio [HR] 0·88 [95% CI 0·57-1·35]; p=0·005 for non-inferiority of IMPT). Overall survival rates after IMPT were 90·9% at 5 years versus 81·0% after IMRT (HR 0·58 [95% CI 0·34-0·99]; p=0·045). Treatment-related deaths occurred in nine patients; six in the IMRT group and three in the IMPT group. Deaths from disease progression occurred in 27 patients; 18 in the IMRT group and nine in the IMPT group. 5-year disease control rates for IMPT versus IMRT were similar between treatment groups (local recurrences 2·9% vs 5·6%, p=0·474; regional recurrences 3·4% vs 3·2%, p=0·860; and distant metastases 9·1% vs 8·9%, p=0·897). Severe lymphopenia was more common in the IMRT group (89% vs 76%), as were dysphagia (49% vs 31%), xerostomia (45% vs 33%), and gastrostomy tube dependence (40·2% vs 26·8%; p=0·018). INTERPRETATION: IMPT showed non-inferiority to IMRT for progression-free survival, improvement in overall survival, similar disease control, and reduced high-grade toxicity relative to IMRT. Treatment-related and post-progression deaths occurred more frequently with IMRT. IMPT is a new standard-of-care treatment option for patients with oropharyngeal cancer. FUNDING: MD Anderson Cancer Center, Massachusetts General Hospital, National Institutes of Health, Hitachi America.

KM 提取结果

2 个 Figure · 4 个 KM 面板

进入结果中心
KM Figure2 个面板

Figure 2

Figure 2: Progression-free survival in the intention-to-treat population (A) and the per-protocol population (B) HR=hazard ratio.

A

progression-free survival

Figure 2 · Panel A

complete 待 EXE 对齐 预期 2 条 已提取 2 条

Panel A 是同一 Figure 2 中的独立 KM 子图;人群、终点或分析条件以本 Panel 图注语义为准。

查看结果
B

progression-free survival

Figure 2 · Panel B

complete 待 EXE 对齐 预期 2 条 已提取 2 条

Panel B 是同一 Figure 2 中的独立 KM 子图;人群、终点或分析条件以本 Panel 图注语义为准。

查看结果
KM Figure2 个面板

Figure 3

Figure 3: Overall survival in the intention-to-treat population (A) and the per-protocol population (B) HR=hazard ratio.

A

Overall survival

Figure 3 · Panel A

complete 待 EXE 对齐 预期 2 条 已提取 2 条

Panel A 是同一 Figure 3 中的独立 KM 子图;人群、终点或分析条件以本 Panel 图注语义为准。

查看结果
B

Overall survival

Figure 3 · Panel B

complete 待 EXE 对齐 预期 2 条 已提取 2 条

Panel B 是同一 Figure 3 中的独立 KM 子图;人群、终点或分析条件以本 Panel 图注语义为准。

查看结果
其他 Figure(3,默认折叠)

这些图片未产生 KM 曲线结果,不在主页面重复展示。

Figure 1Figure 1: Trial profile
非 KM Figure
Figure 4Figure 4: Subgroup analysis of overall survival in the intention-to-treat population Data are number of events/number of patients at risk. HR=hazard ratio. HPV=human papillomavirus.
非 KM Figure
Figure 5Figure 5: Cumulative incidence of gastrostomy-tube dependence in the per-protocol population Patients with prophylactic gastrostomy tubes were excluded, four patients in the intensity-modulated radiation therapy group and six patients in the intensity-modulated proton therapy group.
非 KM Figure