The effect of lobar versus sublobar video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery lung resection on patient quality of life.
Lyndon C Walsh, Joseph Seitlinger, Morgan S Gold, Mark Sorin, Francesca Fermi, James Tankel, Merav Rokah, Roni Rayes, David Mulder, Christian Sirois, Jonathan Cools-Lartigue, Sara Najmeh, Lorenzo Ferri, Julio F Fiore, Jonathan D Spicer
J Thorac Dis 17(11) 10138-10148
摘要
摘要
BACKGROUND: The debate regarding the optimal extent of resection for early-stage lung cancer continues despite 2 major phase 3 trials, yet data regarding patient quality of life (QoL) comparing lobar and sublobar resections is lacking. This study aimed to characterize changes to QoL in the short-term postoperative timeline. METHODS: A single center retrospective study reviewed patients from 2017-2021 who underwent video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) lobectomy, segmentectomy, and wedge resection for primary lung cancer. QoL was assessed using the Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale (ESAS) and the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-Lung (FACT-L). Univariate and regression analyses were performed to assess approaches. RESULTS: Altogether, 134 patients met the inclusion criteria: lobectomies 65% (87/134), segmentectomies 17% (23/134), and wedge resections 18% (24/134). Stage I disease represented 73% (98/134), stage II 19% (26/134), and stage III 8% (10/134). Patients undergoing wedge resections did not experience a significant change in pre- versus postoperative FACT-L, and in fact experienced a decrease in anxiety (pre-op: 2.42±3.06 vs. post-op: 1.33±2.20; P=0.02). Similarly, patients undergoing segmentectomy had no change in FACT-L scores, yet they experienced an increase in the ESAS domains of pain (pre-op: 0.87±1.33 vs. post-op: 3.17±2.35; P<0.001), fatigue (pre-op: 2.30±2.23 vs. post-op: 4.17±2.37; P=0.01) and shortness of breath (pre-op: 2.26±2.54 vs. post-op: 3.91±2.97; P=0.01). Patients who underwent lobectomy experienced a decrease in QoL based on FACT-L (pre-op: 104.90±17.52 vs. post-op: 93.77±19.04; P<0.001), driven largely by changes in the domains for pain (pre-op: 1.54±2.31 vs. post-op: 3.13±2.16; P<0.001), fatigue (pre-op: 2.67±3.00 vs. post-op: 3.76±2.75; P=0.01), appetite (pre-op: 2.49±3.35 vs. post-op: 3.55±3.34; P=0.045), depression (pre-op: 0.59±1.87 vs. post-op: 1.08±2.08; P=0.03) and shortness of breath (pre-op: 2.05±2.74 vs. post-op: 3.90±2.75; P<0.001). These findings were unrelated to length of stay, operative time and surgical complications. CONCLUSIONS: Amongst patients undergoing minimal access pulmonary surgery, the extent of pulmonary resection may influence early postoperative QoL. These non-randomized data are hypothesis generating and suggest that patients undergoing sublobar resections may experience a faster return to baseline QoL as compared to those who undergo lobectomy.
KM 提取结果
0 个 Figure · 0 个 KM 面板