KM Research Hub

FIXED FIVE-YEAR COHORT AUDIT

近五年文献重新检索与对照

旧查询复现与严格 v3 为主比较;历史库存和广召回仅用于解释差异与检查漏检。

complete · complete 汇总 CSV 明细 CSV
固定日期2021-07-29 至 2026-07-29
入排版本oncology-definitive-rct-km-v3
并集论文20925
批次键five-year-20210729-20260729-v1

四个独立队列

数字为批次中保存的原始 PMID 数,不会随着日常监测改变。

历史库存参照组 13065 audit_reference · server-inventory-snapshot-v1
旧查询复现组 7069 primary_legacy · legacy-phase3-fulltext-v1
严格 v3 主组 4707 primary_new · oncology-phase3-survival-strict-v3
v3 广召回影子组 13640 recall_audit · oncology-phase3-survival-discovery-v3

集合关系

交集和差集均按 PMID 精确计算;DOI 只用于明细核对。

比较交集左组独有右组独有
历史库存 ↔ 旧查询复现 7028 6037 41
旧查询复现 ↔ 严格 v3 2464 4605 2243
严格 v3 ↔ 广召回影子组 4707 0 8933
严格查询未命中、但影子组经 v3 筛选后合格 166 篇

元数据入排

20925 / 20925 已完成

KM 证据

仅检查 v3 元数据合格论文,不运行曲线数字化。

论文明细

共 4707 篇;可组合筛选集合关系、入排结果和 KM 证据。

论文队列集合关系v3 入排KM 证据
Addition of androgen receptor-targeted agents to androgen-deprivation therapy and docetaxel in metastatic hormone-sensitive prostate cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PMID 36152486 · ESMO Open · 2022-Oct 记录类型属于综述、Meta 分析、社论、评论、病例或指南。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedexcluded_publication_type pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Trilaciclib prior to gemcitabine plus carboplatin for metastatic triple-negative breast cancer: phase III PRESERVE 2. PMID 36135712 · Future Oncol · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Pembrolizumab versus placebo as adjuvant therapy for completely resected stage IB-IIIA non-small-cell lung cancer (PEARLS/KEYNOTE-091): an interim analysis of a randomised, triple-blind, phase 3 trial. PMID 36108662 · Lancet Oncol · 2022-Oct 原始人体肿瘤 Phase III 随机药物试验,并报告 time-to-event 疗效结局。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligiblephase3_publication_type needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Efficacy and safety of neoadjuvant therapy for triple-negative breast cancer: a Bayesian network meta-analysis. PMID 36103214 · Expert Rev Anticancer Ther · 2022-Oct This is a network meta-analysis of multiple trials, not an original report of a single trial. The primary endpoint is pCR (a binary outcome), not a time-to-event endpoint like OS, PFS, or DFS.
S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedmodel_adjudicated_excluded pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
MAJIC: a phase III trial of acalabrutinib + venetoclax versus venetoclax + obinutuzumab in previously untreated chronic lymphocytic leukemia or small lymphocytic lymphoma. PMID 36102212 · Future Oncol · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Tebentafusp for the treatment of HLA-A*02:01-positive adult patients with unresectable or metastatic uveal melanoma. PMID 36102132 · Expert Rev Anticancer Ther · 2022-Oct 记录类型属于综述、Meta 分析、社论、评论、病例或指南。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedexcluded_publication_type pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Rezvilutamide versus bicalutamide in combination with androgen-deprivation therapy in patients with high-volume, metastatic, hormone-sensitive prostate cancer (CHART): a randomised, open-label, phase 3 trial. PMID 36075260 · Lancet Oncol · 2022-Oct 原始人体肿瘤 Phase III 随机药物试验,并报告 time-to-event 疗效结局。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligiblephase3_publication_type needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Lenalidomide-dexamethasone versus observation in high-risk smoldering myeloma after 12 years of median follow-up time: A randomized, open-label study. PMID 36067617 · Eur J Cancer · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Maintenance olaparib plus bevacizumab in patients with newly diagnosed advanced high-grade ovarian cancer: Main analysis of second progression-free survival in the phase III PAOLA-1/ENGOT-ov25 trial. PMID 36067615 · Eur J Cancer · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
EPIK-O/ENGOT-OV61: alpelisib plus olaparib vs cytotoxic chemotherapy in high-grade serous ovarian cancer (phase III study). PMID 36066851 · Future Oncol · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Patient-reported outcomes with olaparib plus abiraterone versus placebo plus abiraterone for metastatic castration-resistant prostate cancer: a randomised, double-blind, phase 2 trial. PMID 36063830 · Lancet Oncol · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Recurrence-free survival versus overall survival as a primary endpoint for studies of resected colorectal liver metastasis: a retrospective study and meta-analysis. PMID 36058227 · Lancet Oncol · 2022-Oct 记录类型属于综述、Meta 分析、社论、评论、病例或指南。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedexcluded_publication_type pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Survival outcomes in a prospective randomized multicenter Phase III trial comparing patients undergoing anatomical segmentectomy versus standard lobectomy for non-small cell lung cancer up to 2 cm. PMID 36058174 · Lung Cancer · 2022-Oct Eligibility requires a drug-containing intervention. This trial compares surgical techniques, which is a non-drug-only intervention.
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 excludedmodel_adjudicated_excluded pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Trajectories of body weight change and survival among patients with mCRC treated with systemic therapy: Pooled analysis from the ARCAD database. PMID 35994794 · Eur J Cancer · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
A phase III randomized, controlled trial of nedaplatin versus cisplatin concurrent chemoradiotherapy in patients with cervical cancer. PMID 35994789 · ESMO Open · 2022-Oct 原始人体肿瘤 Phase III 随机药物试验,并报告 time-to-event 疗效结局。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligiblephase3_publication_type needs_review 1 Figure · 10 Panel · risk not_visible
Impact of first-line FOLFIRINOX versus Gemcitabine/Nab-Paclitaxel chemotherapy on survival in advanced pancreatic cancer: Evidence from the prospective international multicentre PURPLE pancreatic cancer registry. PMID 35988408 · Eur J Cancer · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Comparative efficacy of novel combination strategies for unresectable hepatocellular carcinoma: A network metanalysis of phase III trials. PMID 35970037 · Eur J Cancer · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Safety and efficacy of S-IROX (S-1, irinotecan and oxaliplatin combination therapy) in patients with advanced pancreatic cancer: A multicenter phase 1b dose-escalation and dose-expansion clinical trial. PMID 35970035 · Eur J Cancer · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Molecular determinants of outcomes in relapsed or refractory mantle cell lymphoma treated with ibrutinib or temsirolimus in the MCL3001 (RAY) trial. PMID 35963941 · Leukemia · 2022-Oct The record is from an oncology Phase III randomized trial with a drug intervention. However, the abstract describes a biomarker and prognostic factor analysis performed on archived material from the trial. It does not report the trial's primary or key secondary time-to-event efficacy results (e.g., OS, PFS, with associated KM curves or HR). Therefore, it is not an eligible report of the trial's efficacy outcomes for this cohort.
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 excludedmodel_adjudicated_excluded pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
EMPOWER CERVICAL-1: Effects of cemiplimab versus chemotherapy on patient-reported quality of life, functioning and symptoms among women with recurrent cervical cancer. PMID 35922251 · Eur J Cancer · 2022-Oct The record reports results of patient-reported outcomes (quality of life, functioning, symptoms) as secondary endpoints in a Phase III randomized trial. It does not report a primary or key secondary time-to-event efficacy endpoint (e.g., OS, PFS) with Kaplan-Meier or HR data, which is required for inclusion.
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 excludedmodel_adjudicated_excluded pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Health-related Quality of Life Analysis from KEYNOTE-426: Pembrolizumab plus Axitinib Versus Sunitinib for Advanced Renal Cell Carcinoma. PMID 35843776 · Eur Urol · 2022-Oct 属于事后亚组、二次、生活质量或卫生经济学分析,不作为原始随机试验结果纳入。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedpost_hoc_or_secondary_analysis pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Impact on xerostomia for nasopharyngeal carcinoma patients treated with superficial parotid lobe-sparing intensity-modulated radiation therapy (SPLS-IMRT): A prospective phase II randomized controlled study. PMID 35817320 · Radiother Oncol · 2022-Oct The study is an oncology, human, randomized, Phase II/III trial with time-to-event endpoints (OS, LRRFS, DMFS), but it lacks a drug-containing intervention (intervention is radiation therapy technique). Therefore, it does not meet the core eligibility criterion of a drug-containing intervention.
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 excludedmodel_adjudicated_excluded pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Outcomes of children with well-differentiated fetal hepatoblastoma treated with surgery only: Report from Children's Oncology Group Trial, AHEP0731. PMID 35810020 · J Pediatr Surg · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized confirmed 1 Figure · 1 Panel · risk visible
Association of genetic variants with patient reported quality of life and pain experience in patients in the UK NCRI Myeloma X Relapse [Intensive]) trial; an exploratory study. PMID 35768571 · Bone Marrow Transplant · 2022-Oct The study is an exploratory analysis of genetic variants associated with patient-reported quality of life and pain within a Phase III randomized trial in multiple myeloma. While it is oncology, human, randomized, and phase 3, it does not involve a primary or key secondary time-to-event efficacy endpoint (OS, PFS, etc.) and is focused on quality-of-life/biomarker associations, not the core drug efficacy analysis. Therefore, it is excluded from the Kaplan-Meier digitization cohort.
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 excludedmodel_adjudicated_excluded pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
CPX-351 Yields Similar Response and Survival Outcome in Younger and Older Patients With Secondary Acute Myeloid Leukemia. PMID 35760672 · Clin Lymphoma Myeloma Leuk · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Efficacy and Safety of Befotertinib (D-0316) in Patients With EGFR T790M-Mutated NSCLC That Had Progressed After Prior EGFR Tyrosine Kinase Inhibitor Therapy: A Phase 2, Multicenter, Single-Arm, Open-Label Study. PMID 35724798 · J Thorac Oncol · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
The role of plasma exosomal lnc-SNAPC5-3:4 in monitoring the efficacy of anlotinib in the treatment of advanced non-small cell lung cancer. PMID 35672525 · J Cancer Res Clin Oncol · 2022-Oct 原始人体肿瘤 Phase III 随机药物试验,并报告 time-to-event 疗效结局。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligiblephase3_publication_type needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
First-line pembrolizumab + chemotherapy in Japanese patients with advanced/metastatic esophageal cancer from KEYNOTE-590. PMID 35668304 · Esophagus · 2022-Oct 属于事后亚组、二次、生活质量或卫生经济学分析,不作为原始随机试验结果纳入。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedpost_hoc_or_secondary_analysis pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Oral metronomic chemotherapy after definitive chemoradiation in esophageal squamous cell carcinoma: a randomized clinical trial. PMID 35614161 · Esophagus · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Lenvatinib plus pembrolizumab in Japanese patients with endometrial cancer: Results from Study 309/KEYNOTE-775. PMID 35612971 · Cancer Sci · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized confirmed 2 Figure · 4 Panel · risk visible
Isatuximab plus carfilzomib and dexamethasone in East Asian patients with relapsed multiple myeloma: IKEMA subgroup analysis. PMID 35578151 · Int J Hematol · 2022-Oct 属于事后亚组、二次、生活质量或卫生经济学分析,不作为原始随机试验结果纳入。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedpost_hoc_or_secondary_analysis pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Health-related Quality of Life with Adjuvant Nivolumab After Radical Resection for High-risk Muscle-invasive Urothelial Carcinoma: Results from the Phase 3 CheckMate 274 Trial. PMID 35288066 · Eur Urol Oncol · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized confirmed 2 Figure · 5 Panel · risk visible
Austria-based real-world data on bevacizumab in newly diagnosed epithelial ovarian cancer. PMID 35146539 · Wien Klin Wochenschr · 2022-Oct 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized confirmed 1 Figure · 1 Panel · risk visible
Physical Activity Program for the Survival of Elderly Patients With Lymphoma: Study Protocol for Randomized Phase 3 Trial. PMID 36427234 · JMIR Res Protoc · 2022-Nov-25 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized no_km 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_applicable
Patient-reported outcomes in ZUMA-7, a phase 3 study of axicabtagene ciloleucel in second-line large B-cell lymphoma. PMID 35839452 · Blood · 2022-Nov-24 原始人体肿瘤 Phase III 随机药物试验,并报告 time-to-event 疗效结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligiblephase3_publication_type needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
BOREAS: a global, phase III study of the MDM2 inhibitor navtemadlin (KRT-232) in relapsed/refractory myelofibrosis. PMID 36416118 · Future Oncol · 2022-Nov-23 记录类型属于综述、Meta 分析、社论、评论、病例或指南。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedexcluded_publication_type pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
An effective and chemotherapy-free strategy of all-trans retinoic acid and arsenic trioxide for acute promyelocytic leukemia in all risk groups (APL15 trial). PMID 36404343 · Blood Cancer J · 2022-Nov-21 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized confirmed 1 Figure · 3 Panel · risk visible
Oxaliplatin (3 months v 6 months) With 6 Months of Fluoropyrimidine as Adjuvant Therapy in Patients With Stage II/III Colon Cancer: KCSG CO09-07. PMID 35772045 · J Clin Oncol · 2022-Nov-20 命中用户提供的消化道肿瘤阳性参考集。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligiblepositive_reference confirmed 4 Figure · 8 Panel · risk visible
Risk and response adapted therapy following autologous stem cell transplant in patients with newly diagnosed multiple myeloma (RADAR (UK-MRA Myeloma XV Trial): study protocol for a phase II/III randomised controlled trial. PMID 36396306 · BMJ Open · 2022-Nov-17 方案论文未报告临床试验结果。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedprotocol_without_results pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Stereotactic Radiotherapy after Incomplete Transarterial (Chemo-) Embolization (TAE\TACE) versus Exclusive TAE or TACE for Treatment of Inoperable HCC: A Phase III Trial (NCT02323360). PMID 36421345 · Curr Oncol · 2022-Nov-16 The trial compares radiotherapy (SBRT) versus another local therapy (TAE/TACE), both non-drug interventions. It does not contain a drug-containing intervention arm.
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 excludedmodel_adjudicated_excluded pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Protocol for the postoperative radiotherapy in N1 breast cancer patients (PORT-N1) trial, a prospective multicenter, randomized, controlled, non-inferiority trial of patients receiving breast-conserving surgery or mastectomy. PMID 36384573 · BMC Cancer · 2022-Nov-16 方案论文未报告临床试验结果。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedprotocol_without_results pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
EMT-Related Genes Have No Prognostic Relevance in Metastatic Colorectal Cancer as Opposed to Stage II/III: Analysis of the Randomised, Phase III Trial FIRE-3 (AIO KRK 0306; FIRE-3). PMID 36428688 · Cancers (Basel) · 2022-Nov-14 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Lenvatinib as First-Line Treatment for Unresectable Hepatocellular Carcinoma: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. PMID 36428618 · Cancers (Basel) · 2022-Nov-10 记录类型属于综述、Meta 分析、社论、评论、病例或指南。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedexcluded_publication_type pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
FLOT Versus FLOT/Trastuzumab/Pertuzumab Perioperative Therapy of Human Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor 2-Positive Resectable Esophagogastric Adenocarcinoma: A Randomized Phase II Trial of the AIO EGA Study Group. PMID 35709415 · J Clin Oncol · 2022-Nov-10 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Everolimus Added to Adjuvant Endocrine Therapy in Patients With High-Risk Hormone Receptor-Positive, Human Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor 2-Negative Primary Breast Cancer. PMID 35605174 · J Clin Oncol · 2022-Nov-10 原始人体肿瘤 Phase III 随机药物试验,并报告 time-to-event 疗效结局。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligiblephase3_publication_type needs_review 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_assessed
Efficacy and safety of PARP inhibitors in elderly patients with advanced ovarian cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PMID 36229080 · Int J Gynecol Cancer · 2022-Nov-07 明确的 Phase III/IIIb/II-III 随机肿瘤药物试验,且报告 time-to-event 结局。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 eligibleexplicit_phase3_randomized no_km 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk not_applicable
The Evolving Scenario in the Assessment of Radiological Response for Hepatocellular Carcinoma in the Era of Immunotherapy: Strengths and Weaknesses of Surrogate Endpoints. PMID 36359347 · Biomedicines · 2022-Nov-06 记录类型属于综述、Meta 分析、社论、评论、病例或指南。
H S B
严格 v3 独有 excludedexcluded_publication_type pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Brentuximab Vedotin with Chemotherapy in Pediatric High-Risk Hodgkin's Lymphoma. PMID 36322844 · N Engl J Med · 2022-Nov-03 原始人体肿瘤 Phase III 随机药物试验,并报告 time-to-event 疗效结局。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligiblephase3_publication_type confirmed 2 Figure · 3 Panel · risk visible
Bias and Type I error Control in Correcting Treatment Effect for Treatment Switching Using Marginal Structural Models in Phase III Oncology Trials. PMID 35656809 · J Biopharm Stat · 2022-Nov-02 The record describes a methodological study analyzing statistical methods (MSMs) for correcting treatment switching bias in RCTs, using simulations and a case study. It does not present original results of a specific randomized trial with a drug intervention and a primary/key secondary time-to-event efficacy endpoint.
H S B
严格 v3 独有 needs_reviewmodel_uncertain pending 0 Figure · 0 Panel · risk -
Phase III trial of chemoradiotherapy with temozolomide plus nivolumab or placebo for newly diagnosed glioblastoma with methylated MGMT promoter. PMID 35511454 · Neuro Oncol · 2022-Nov-02 原始人体肿瘤 Phase III 随机药物试验,并报告 time-to-event 疗效结局。
H L S B
旧组与严格 v3 交集 eligiblephase3_publication_type confirmed 3 Figure · 8 Panel · risk visible